About Our Agency

Allen & Stults Co., Inc. provides comprehensive insurance options throughout New Jersey, Eastern Pennsylvania, and Southern New York with offices in Hightstown.

Home » About Our Agency

We are your trusted independent insurance agency.

Your family, your business and your possessions are all important to you, but you may not know how to best protect them. We have the experience to navigate the unique risks you face, serving as your insurance advisor.

Allen & Stults Co., Inc. is a Trusted Choice independent insurance agency. Established in Hightstown in 1881 by John Allen & Charles Stults, the agency is currently operated by the fifth generation of the Stults family. For more than 130 years we have served the families, businesses and non-profit organizations of New Jersey and the surrounding areas. We have grown along with the community and continue to be a company dedicated to providing personalized service to our clients.

Although we are still at our original small town location at 100-106 North Main Street, Allen & Stults Co., Inc. has always been recognized as a leading insurance agency in New Jersey.

We are not only committed to our clients, but remain a strong presence within the insurance industry. Throughout the years, our agency owners have lead both state and national independent insurance organizations providing input and support regarding coverage, ethics and legislative reform.

Allen & Stults Co., Inc. is proud of its history and knows what is important to our clients – a professional, caring staff and a strong, reliable insurance company. We are fully committed to staff continuing education and are constantly upgrading our technology to meet your needs. At the same time, we do not lose sight of our reputation as a family owned, personal service oriented organization. You can always reach us and talk to real people who are familiar with you and your needs.

130 years

serving New Jersey and surrounding areas


we were established in Hightstown, NJ


generation agency

Start Quote Request
What does being a Trusted Choice Agency mean?

Trusted Choice® was created exclusively for Big “I” members to help consumers understand the value that an independent agent/agency offers. Agents and agencies apart of Trusted Choice commit to the “Pledge of Performance.”

We take being an “independent agency” seriously, striving to provide exceptional value and service to every one of our clients.

The Pledge of Performance
  • Work with you to identify the insurance and financial services that are right for you, your family or your business and use our access to multiple companies to deliver those products.
  • Guide you through the claims process for a prompt and fair resolution of your claim.
  • Help you solve problems related to your coverage or account.
  • Explain the coverages and options available to you through our agency, at your request.
  • Return your phone calls and e-mails promptly and respond to your requests in a timely manner.
  • Provide 24/7 services for our customers, offering any or all of the following: emergency phone numbers, Internet account access, e-mail and call center services.
  • Use our experience and multiple company relationships to customize your coverage as needed.
  • Commit our staff to continuing education so they may be more knowledgeable in serving you.
  • Treat you with respect and courtesy.
  • Conduct our business in an ethical manner.

As an independent insurance agency we have great relationships with many well-known, reputable insurance companies, giving you the power of choice.


Our insurance advisors have years of experience in the insurance industry and serve as your advocate from selecting coverage through filing a claim.


Our insurance advisors have a strong passion for insurance and protecting what you value most in business and in life. We treat our customers like family.

At Allen & Stults Co., Inc., our mission is very simple. We strive to provide a true, concierge client experience which is unique in the insurance industry. We give clients the power of choice from top-rated national and regional insurance carriers. We offer comprehensive insurance solutions throughout New Jersey, Eastern Pennsylvania, and Southern New York with offices in Hightstown.

Insurance Quote Request

As an independent agency, we offer multiple options at competitive prices.

  • Coverage will not be bound or changed until confirmed by a licensed agent.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.