About Us

For more than 140 years and across five generations, Allen & Stults Co., Inc. has served the families, businesses and non-profit organizations of New Jersey and the surrounding areas.

Established in Hightstown in 1881 by John Allen & Charles Stults, the agency is currently operated by the fifth generation of the Stults family.  We are a Trusted Choice independent insurance agency and have grown along with the community and continue to be a company dedicated to providing personalized service to our clients.

Allen & Stults Co., Inc. has always been recognized as a leading insurance agency in New Jersey. We are not only committed to our clients but remain a strong presence within the insurance industry. Throughout the years, our agency owners have led both state and national independent insurance organizations providing input and support regarding coverage, ethics and legislative reform.

Allen & Stults Co., Inc. is proud of its history and knows what is important to our clients – a professional, caring staff and a strong, reliable insurance company. We are fully committed to staff continuing education and are constantly upgrading our technology to meet your needs. At the same time, we do not lose sight of our reputation as a family-owned, personal service-oriented organization. You can always reach us and talk to real people who are familiar with you and your needs.

What makes our insurance agency special:

  • We offer a wide variety of insurance products and have a large selection of companies to choose from to meet your coverage needs.
  • We leverage digital technology to improve communication with clients and streamline operations.
  • We have a strong local presence and pride ourselves in our involvement with community organizations, small businesses and non-profits.
  • Longevity is a common trait among our employees, most of whom have spent the majority of their careers with us.
  • We take a collaborative approach to problem-solving, with specialists in each department.
  • We proactively review coverages and make recommendations to help clients manage their risk.

Trusted Choice Independent Insurance Agents

Trusted Choice® was created exclusively for Big “I” members to help consumers understand the value that an independent agent/agency offers. We take being an “independent agency” seriously, striving to provide exceptional value and service to every one of our clients. Our agents are all committed to the part of Trusted Choice “Pledge of Performance.”

Meet The Team

Charles "Cappy" Stults

President

Greg Byrne

Vice-President/Office Manager

Gerald Ford

Vice-President/Commercial Lines

Cathy Mazzoli

Vice-President/Personal Lines Supervisor

William Daly

Vice-President/Employee Benefits

Brent Rivenburgh

Vice-President/Commercial Lines

Deborah Corrington

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Gail Lanza

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Cathy McAuliffe

Commercial Lines Account Representative

Adam Overmyer

Personal Lines Account Executive

Katie Fisher

Personal Lines Account Manager

Michelle Field

Employee Benefits Account Manager

Abigail Stults Rivenburgh

Human Resources Director

Apply for a position with Allen & Stults Co., Inc.

    Join Our Team:

    At Allen & Stults Co., Inc., we believe your career should be much more than just a job you show up to. We strive to create an open environment where team members love to come to work and interact with each other and clients.

    Our agency has a strong presence in the local community, and we’d love for you to be a part of it for many years to come. Each employee has the unwavering support of ownership, and many of our clients have been loyal to us for decades.

    We’re always seeking new personal and commercial producers, account executives, and customer service representatives to join us. Become part of the team and enjoy these benefits as you take your career to the next level:

    • Profit-Sharing
    • 401(k) Option
    • Medical Benefits
    • Life Insurance
    • Training and Continuing Education
    • Paid Vacation
    • Paid Holidays

    Affiliations


    Get a Quote