Over 140 years of servingour clients and community.

We are a fifth-generation, Trusted Choice agency, serving New Jersey, Southern New York, and Eastern Pennsylvania.

Request A Quote

Impeccable Service Spanning Across Five Generations

Allen & Stults Co., Inc. is a Trusted Choice independent insurance agency offering a comprehensive suite of insurance solutions. Established by John Allen & Charles Stults in Hightstown in 1881, the fifth generation of the Stults family currently operates the agency.

For over 140 years we have served families, businesses and non-profit organizations across New Jersey and surrounding areas. As we have grown, so have our deep connections with our community and clientele.

About Our Agency

COVID-19 Updates

We’re proud to have stayed open every day throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, whether it has been working in the office or remotely.

For clients who need to visit our office, please call ahead (609-448-0110) and one of our staff members will be glad to meet you Monday through Friday, 8:30 – 5:00.

COVID-19 Resources

Insurance Specialties

What does being a Trusted Choice Agency mean?

Trusted Choice® was created exclusively for Big “I” members to help consumers understand the value that an independent agent/agency offers. Agents and agencies apart of Trusted Choice commit to the “Pledge of Performance.”


Latest Articles

Tornado Hits While Driving

Seeing a tornado while driving can be terrifying. Being prepared and knowing what to do ahead of time can be the difference between life and death. Here are…

Read More

snowy street in NJ

Winterizing Your Home in New Jersey

Winterizing your home is very important. It should be done not only to avoid claims, but also to decrease your power bills. An example of a claim is water…

Read More

Lost Your Health Insurance Because of a Job Loss? There Are Options

WE can help you review your Medical plan options and replace the health insurance plan that was provide by your former employer. Quality, affordable health…

Read More


Get a Quote